Root cause analysis in practice
The first answer to "why did it happen?" is often a symptom, and it often points at a person: "he was careless" or "the procedure was not followed". But that is rarely the whole explanation. Root cause analysis is about finding what actually needs to change so it does not happen again.
From blame to learning
For a long time, people looked for the fault in whoever did the job. In recent years that view has changed, also in Norwegian industry. With HOP (Human and Organizational Performance), which draws on experience from aviation and nuclear power among others, you ask instead what made the job difficult. The starting point is:
- Error is normal, even among skilled people.
- Blame fixes nothing.
- Context shapes what people do.
The goal is to fix the work, not the person doing it.
How to use the 5 Whys
A simple method is the "5 Whys". You ask why, and then why again about the answer, until you reach a cause that can be removed. It does not have to be exactly five times. An example:
- There is oil on the floor. Why?
- The hose is worn. Why?
- It was not replaced in time. Why?
- It is not in the maintenance routine.
Then the action is not just to replace the hose, but to add replacing all hoses to a routine.
Look for several causes
Incidents rarely have a single root cause. Often several factors work together, such as time pressure, unclear procedures or equipment that does not fit. Do not stop at answers like "human error" either. Keep asking until you find what in the system made the error possible.
When you talk to the people involved, it works better to ask "can you describe what happened?" than "why did you do that?". You learn more. What the people involved did usually made sense at the time, and that is exactly why it is worth learning from.
Actions that work
Immediate actions are important to put right what happened and keep anyone from getting hurt. But actions that only fix what is visible, or that target the individual, often lead to the same incident or nonconformity again. Changes to the system, such as equipment, organisation and procedures, last longer.
A good root cause analysis does not look for someone to blame, but for the explanation. It is the basis for actions that actually work.
